The MD theses, finally, are over. Focused research questions, great introductions, meticulous methods, well-laid out results and structured discussions. But what the theses won’t have this year is their most readable section – acknowledgements. The section, guides loved to leaf through in the close confines of their office. The section that boosted their self-esteem. The section that created an illusion in their mind that they were an embodiment of successful researchers, crafty clinicians and humane human beings.
Now that the residents are all set to submit their theses to the MUHS, Nashik, they would have to format the manuscript according to the revised rules and regulations. According to the MUHS, a thesis should be stripped off all identifiers: names, affiliations, and locations. The idea is that a manuscript, stripped of all identifiers would allow an unbiased and dispassionate review.
That is fine. Biases and prejudices do distort the assessment. But in the process, the University has deprived the guides of the pleasure that the acknowledgement section generated for decades.
Till recently, soon after the guides signed the thesis, and residents left behind (a parker pen) and a copy of fresh leather-bound thesis on their desk, the guides would quickly open the section that we were yearning to go through. No, this was not results, discussion or summary and conclusion. They were eyeing the acknowledgement section. They needed absolute privacy to read this section -word-by-word. For, they expected heaps of praise showered on them by their resident. And they were seldom disappointed.
What a wonderful series of adjectives the residents picked up to describe their guides- “brilliant, sparkling, knowledgeable, erudite, astuteโฆ” Where else would the guides find those ego-pampering hyperboles: “lucky to have been trained under him”; “painstakingly explained and guided me at every step of my thesis”; “was an epitome of knowledge, wisdom and insight”; “his impeccable understanding of study designs and statistics helped me unravel the complexities of medical research”, or “it was dream come true to find such a mentor”!
For several years, I naively believed that these words came straight from the heart. Till a medicine lecturer shattered my blissful ignorance. “Residents write acknowledgments”, he said, “a couple of hours before they take the manuscript to the book-binder.” Tired, traumatized and tormented, they are no longer in a frame of mind that would let them write a creative prose. The baby – the thesis- is out but the placenta – the acknowledgments-needs to be delivered now. They need to design a section that would deftly disguise their guide’s whims, fancies, and idiosyncrasies. Instead, they want to paint their guides through the choicest of colours and hues. So who do they assign this task? In the good old days, a clever typist in the institute had a handful of ready-made templates โ all that he needed to know was the guide and the department! Fervently typing 60-words a minute, in no time would he deftly generate an effusive acknowledgement, a write-up that would make an impressive reading. Sometimes, the residents would ask their convent-educated juniors to write flowery English. And now, with the Microsoft word on their laptops, residents have discovered that finding synonyms and paraphrasing the prose takes just a couple of mouse clicks!
And so, this week, as I would browse through my copy of the manuscript and try to find my way through the maze of graphs, tables and numbers, my eyes won’t find the section, so dear to my heart. The thesis, nameless and faceless, would lack those two pages that every guide privately read but never acknowledged in public.
Dear residents: do not destroy my illusory world. I will trust every sentence that you write to embellish your text. Do tell me that I did not acquire gray hair by a sudden flight; that my spectacular face showcases the distillate of clinical and research wisdom that I painstakingly gathered over years. Tell me that theses are tedious and irksome- even more difficult than twelve labours of Hercules- and but for me you would have toiled fruitlessly downward in the residency nights.
Dear Sir,
That is a very well written piece of prose.
However, I never realized that any one ever read the acknowledgement section of the theses. I always thought that was just a formality that had to be completed. Infact if you remember, my thesis had no acknowledgements. I had written only one line that I wish to thank anybody and everybody who was associated with the thesis. Had I known that the acknowledgements were so dear to the guide, I could have let my heart out on reams of pages. You are scaring me!!
And till now I thought that no one ever reads the acknowledgement section!!!
The fact that acknowledgments is the placenta that come out at last in not always true. True that many a times,it is cut copy paste,but residents I know search the net for the choicest words and apt descriptions for their mentors, search which might even surpase their
bibliography hunts.
Only a few are endowed with a pristine vocabulary so as to express their every thought in words. Hence, net offers a ready source of
expressions for such mediocre Engish writers. But, such net searches are not at all a easy path taken up. The residents pour in all their
emotions in the searches to make the description of their mentor's perfection even more perfect.
And I wouldnt agree more that MUHS had robbed the student of their only chance to put forward their minds which otherwise they dread to
come out with face to face.
That definitely sounds like an obituary of the acknowledgements section. I wonder if the demise was preceded by a thoughtful exercise or was a careless clerical omission.
Some of us have our acknowledgement-horror stories, including mine where the name of my co-guide (who was forced upon me at the last moment) was never there in the acknowledgements. I wonder how must have been the feeling, when I left a copy of the thesis on the table right-after it was signed !!
As I went through it took me back to the time when I was writing my thesis. What I went through has been a history. I am sure, you would also agree with me.
All that you have mentioned is absolutely true, but the other half is that the words that the students mention in their thesis in this particular page are from their heart may be more flowery than most are capable of writing. I personally feel that acknowledgements are written with particular interest by the students as they are also aware of the fact this section would be read by most people.
We all respect you and all the teachers. Everyone at Sevagram has a special place in our hearts and this I am stating on behalf of all the students.
As I went through it took me back to the time when I was writing my thesis. What I went through has been a history. I am sure, you would also agree with me.
All that you have mentioned is absolutely true, but the other half is that the words that the students mention in their thesis in this particular page are from their heart may be more flowery than most are capable of writing. I personally feel that acknowledgements are written with particular interest by the students as they are also aware of the fact this section would be read by most people.
We all respect you and all the teachers. Everyone at Sevagram has a special place in our hearts and this I am stating on behalf of all the students.
I would beg to differ, and agree to disagree with it not in its entirety, but in part. A lot of the theses acknowledgements, I believe do come from the heart. I acknowledge that the circumstances of the moment (nearing the MD exam) may colour thoughts, but the extent to which they do is debatable…Certainly in Sewagram, if not elsewhere….
Even though I have had a chance to work in some hospitals with all facilities, and some very good consultants, I still cherish my MD training and my MGIMS background.
It was a great pleasure to read your mail in trademark immaculate English, brought back the memories of post-graduation and your rounds and clinics. Not only were we inspired to read medicine but I was equally inspired by the command you had over the language. And this does come straight from the heart, no embellishments needed now. Frankly I never felt the need even then, there is no doubt that you inspired everybody and if I had forgotten to voice my gratitude then, I am glad I have now.
Unit four posting was coveted and eagerly awaited, Am sure it is still the same. It was a twist in my story when Dr. Gupta left and I was left orphaned, but I couldn't have asked for more when I was told that you would be my guide. Not all orphans are unlucky.
I truthfully enjoyed my thesis work as I like research and after coming to UK came to know that we are allocated special points while we apply for jobs if we have research experience.
I personally felt you are an amazing teacher as you helped me to overcome my short comings ( making me an IT literate and understand statistics) first before I actually went ahead with the thesis.
I am thankful to have a teacher like you.
I really enjoyed reading this email and truly appreciate your viewpoint. A thesis without the name of the student, guide and institute can be plagiarized easily and misused. The best institutes in the world do not adopt this method which is rather unusual.
It is indeed sad that the practice of writing acknowledgments is getting over in MGIMS. I don't know about others, but I wrote my thesis acknowledgment well in advance. I also know that every guide yearns for a good word from his students (being a MD guide myself now). I do feel that most PGs actually mean what they write about their guide, unless the guide was absolutely horrible. You are also spot on about the "Parker" pen bit; I followed that ritual too and actually felt very happy about it. For a PG, there is nothing better that to see his guide happy when he submits his thesis. Hence I feel acknowledgements are an integral part of any thesis.
Anything done under compulsion can be bore some, irritating, & repulsive. It may still be done mechanically but would lack doerโs touch of heart & honesty. Thesis is something which I do not think as must for PG student. If authorized {hypothetically}, I would decide awarding MD on the basis of actual work done all through the residency years, practical skills acquired & those that are expected from the โwould be consultantโ.
I would also lay emphasis on approach to the patient, interpersonal relationship, how best the medical knowledge acquired is applied in actual clinical situation, professional worthiness & reliability especially when alone & in emergency {in the available settings}. Respect for human values, counseling skills & character would also count. Periodic assessment would be done & grade awarded to the candidate. Opportunities would be given to improve upon and get rid of the deficiencies. Thesis would be optional and if still done properly the student would get extra credits for that.
I feel this method would prove to be more practical and produce more able consultants having three As- ability, availability and affection for patients. Otherwise universities will keep churning out doctors who only have PG degrees and are looked upon by the society as โnecessary evilโ an acknowledgment cum certificate of our system failure!
Good practice started after all. however I would like to make some information added.
Though the MUHS has not asked for any identity students got their personal copy bound in traditional way as they are needed to show at least once when they apply for a job (probably).
University is not going to ask the thesis back from the examiners and all the effort and money (spent on leather finish binding and color printing) is going to go in dustbins after its acceptance.
Wonderful letter! Afraid to praise more lest it sounds an acknowledgement